Calling All Peanut Butter Fans...

I hope you all had a wonderful weekend! Our paddle boarding adventure had to be postponed due to weather while our road trip to Florida was marred by monsoon-like downpours. I'm pretty sure the rain was following us. It caused a bunch of accidents, so this bad traveler was not a happy camper for most of Sunday but we were relieved to have made it safely.

I still can't believe its already June. You know those summer picnics where you can predict what your family is going to serve because its usually one of the first things gone? For my family, this Peanut Butter Cup dessert is it.

I think by now its pretty obvious that I have a major sweet tooth. As if this Instagram photo didn't give it away... But this isn't one of those super sweet, make-your-teeth-hurt, kind of desserts. I know people who aren't crazy about peanut butter and they still love this because the flavor isn't overpowering. Especially when you top it with some chocolate and cool whip!

2 cups Graham Cracker Crumbs
3/4 cup melted butter
2 tsp. Granulated Sugar
2/3 cup Creamy Peanut Butter
1 cup Powdered Sugar
1 (8 oz.) package of Cream Cheese, softened
1 large container of Cool Whip (set 2 cups aside for one of the layers)
1 small package of Chocolate Instant Pudding
1 small package of Vanilla Instant Pudding
2 cups Milk

1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F and grease a 9x13 pan with some butter.

2. Mix together the graham cracker crumbs, granulated sugar, and melted butter. Spread on the bottom of your pan and bake for 10 minutes. Allow to cool completely. (I usually stick it in the fridge for a bit!)

3. While your crust is cooling, mix together the peanut butter, powdered sugar, softened cream cheese, and 2 cups of Cool Whip. I like to use my hand mixer or whisk to make it smooth. Spread this layer on the cooled crust.

 4. Finally, the chocolate layer! Mix together both packages of pudding mix with the milk. Note: Do not follow the pudding recipe on the package, only use 2 cups of milk. Once the mixture is smooth, spread if over the peanut butter layer.

5. Top with the remaining Cool Whip and some shredded chocolate. (I didn't have a candy bar handy and had to shred chocolate chips... it was dangerous, I don't recommend it)

I had to mention that you do not follow the pudding directions on the box because your pudding layer with be way too watery. I did this once when I was taking it to Easter dinner with my husband's extended family (the first time I met them all). It tasted good but looked like a total disaster. #FutureWifeFail

The best part is you don't have to do any baking except for the crust, which makes this much easier to put together than cupcakes or cookies. I took it to our friend's Memorial Day party and it was the only thing gone by the time we left! Hence the reason I didn't get a picture of an individual piece!

Has anyone ever had Peanut Butter Cup Dessert before? It's super easy, I suggest adding it to your summer picnic menu because everyone will love it!


  1. bummer about the rain but OMG this dessert looks sooo good. i love peanut butter! xo jillian - cornflake dreams

  2. This dessert sounds heavenly!! Sorry about your travel plans, but happy that you made it back safe and sound!

  3. Oh this dessert looks so amazing, I am def adding it to my rotation for the summer!! thanks!

  4. boo to weather, but holy amazeballs this looks beyond delish.

  5. This sounds so good! I love peanut butter, but my husband hates anything with peanut butter and chocolate (totally crazy), I'll have to keep this in mind for the time gathering we have though! And I'm impressed you were able to shred chocolate chips!

  6. OMG YUM! I love peanut butter! Literally anything with peanut butter... definitely going to have to try this!

    <3, Pamela

  7. Yum! You and Ally have me craving peanut butter!

  8. Sorry about your travel/trip plans getting messed up :( Well it just so happens I have a jar of pb here in my office, after now reading 2 pb recipe posts, I think I am going to bust it open....

  9. You had me at the title.... YUM

  10. Holy. Crap. I can only make this when my husband is out of town since he has a major love of PB but also a newly-discovered horrible allergy to the stuff. So sad. But so tempting!

  11. YUM. I love peanut butter!

    ~Ashley @ A Cute Angle

  12. That looks and sounds delicious! Going to have to try this out when I take a break from the clean eating/no sugar thing. Hope you're having a great time in FL!

  13. YUM! Peanut butter is my fave, cannot wait to try this.

  14. Oh, you had me at peanut butter that looks delicious!


Powered by Blogger.